Greatest Second Baseman (Round 1)

[Matt]

The voting for this round will end on July 31st at 11:59pm. You guys know how this works.

 

BRACKET ONE

Eddie Collins (Philadelphia Athletics) vs Ron Hunt (New York Mets)

Charlie Gehringer (Detroit Tigers) vs Johnny Temple (Cincinnati Reds)

Ryne Sandberg (Chicago Cubs) vs George Grantham (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Joe Gordon (New York Yankees) vs Dave Cash (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Billy Herman (Chicago Cubs) vs Robby Thompson (San Francisco Giants)

Tony Lazzeri (New York Yankees) vs Davey Johnson (Baltimore Orioles)

Bill Mazeroski (Pittsburgh Pirates) vs Bobby Avila (Cleveland Guardians)

Hardy Richardson (Buffalo Bisons) vs Chuck Knoblauch (Minnesota Twins)

 

BRACKET TWO

Rogers Hornsby (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Glenn Beckert (Chicago Cubs)

Jackie Robinson (Brooklyn Dodgers) vs Danny Murphy (Philadelphia Athletics)

Frankie Frisch (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Claude Ritchey (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Larry Doyle (New York Giants) vs Jim Gantner (Milwaukee Brewers)

Nellie Fox (Chicago White Sox) vs Frank Bolling (Detroit Tigers)

Jeff Kent (San Francisco Giants) vs Phil Garner (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Davey Lopes (Los Angeles Dodgers) vs Gil McDougald (New York Yankees)

Miller Huggins (Cincinnati Reds) vs Kid Gleason (Philadelphia Phillies)

 

BRACKET THREE

Nap Lajoie (Cleveland Guardians) vs Felix Milan (Atlanta Braves)

Craig Biggio (Houston Astros) vs Tony Cuccinello (Boston Braves)

Lou Whitaker (Detroit Tigers) vs Fred Pfeffer (Chicago Cubs)

Willie Randolph (New York Yankees) vs Bobby Lowe (Boston Braves)

Johnny Evers (Chicago Cubs) vs Eddie Stanky (Brooklyn Dodgers)

Red Schoendienst (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Steve Sax (Los Angeles Dodgers)

Dick McAuliffe (Detroit Tigers) vs Lonny Frey (Cincinnati Reds)

Cupid Childs (Cleveland Spiders) vs Frank White (Kansas City Royals)

 

BRACKET FOUR

Joe Morgan (Houston Astros) vs Jimmy Williams (New York Yankees)

Roberto Alomar (Toronto Blue Jays) vs Tom Daly (Brooklyn Dodgers)

Bobby Grich (California Angels) vs Bill Doran (Cleveland Guardians)

Bobby Doerr (Boston Red Sox) vs Tony Taylor (Philadelphia Phillies)

Buddy Myer (Washington Senators) vs Max Bishop (Philadelphia Athletics)

Bid McPhee (Cincinnati Reds) vs Tom Herr (St. Louis Cardinals)

Del Pratt (St. Louis Browns) vs Marty McManus (St. Louis Browns)

Junior Gillam (Los Angeles Dodgers) vs Manny Trillo (Chicago Cubs)

[RavenOfProphecy]

Could you fill me in? I just send in who I think were the best players from each matchup, right?

[RavenOfProphecy]

BRACKET ONE

Eddie Collins (Philadelphia Athletics) vs Ron Hunt (New York Mets)

Charlie Gehringer (Detroit Tigers) vs Johnny Temple (Cincinnati Reds)

Ryne Sandberg (Chicago Cubs) vs George Grantham (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Joe Gordon (New York Yankees) vs Dave Cash (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Billy Herman (Chicago Cubs) vs Robby Thompson (San Francisco Giants)

Tony Lazzeri (New York Yankees) vs Davey Johnson (Baltimore Orioles)

Bill Mazeroski (Pittsburgh Pirates) vs Bobby Avila (Cleveland Guardians)

Hardy Richardson (Buffalo Bisons) vs Chuck Knoblauch (Minnesota Twins)

 

BRACKET TWO

Rogers Hornsby (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Glenn Beckert (Chicago Cubs)

Jackie Robinson (Brooklyn Dodgers) vs Danny Murphy (Philadelphia Athletics)

Frankie Frisch (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Claude Ritchey (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Larry Doyle (New York Giants) vs Jim Gantner (Milwaukee Brewers)

Nellie Fox (Chicago White Sox) vs Frank Bolling (Detroit Tigers)

Jeff Kent (San Francisco Giants) vs Phil Garner (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Davey Lopes (Los Angeles Dodgers) vs Gil McDougald (New York Yankees)

Miller Huggins (Cincinnati Reds) vs Kid Gleason (Philadelphia Phillies)

 

BRACKET THREE

Nap Lajoie (Cleveland Guardians) vs Felix Milan (Atlanta Braves)

Craig Biggio (Houston Astros) vs Tony Cuccinello (Boston Braves)

Lou Whitaker (Detroit Tigers) vs Fred Pfeffer (Chicago Cubs)

Willie Randolph (New York Yankees) vs Bobby Lowe (Boston Braves)

Johnny Evers (Chicago Cubs) vs Eddie Stanky (Brooklyn Dodgers)

Red Schoendienst (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Steve Sax (Los Angeles Dodgers)

Dick McAuliffe (Detroit Tigers) vs Lonny Frey (Cincinnati Reds)

Cupid Childs (Cleveland Spiders) vs Frank White (Kansas City Royals)

 

BRACKET FOUR

Joe Morgan (Houston Astros) vs Jimmy Williams (New York Yankees)

Roberto Alomar (Toronto Blue Jays) vs Tom Daly (Brooklyn Dodgers)

Bobby Grich (California Angels) vs Bill Doran (Cleveland Guardians)

Bobby Doerr (Boston Red Sox) vs Tony Taylor (Philadelphia Phillies)

Buddy Myer (Washington Senators) vs Max Bishop (Philadelphia Athletics)

Bid McPhee (Cincinnati Reds) vs Tom Herr (St. Louis Cardinals)

Del Pratt (St. Louis Browns) vs Marty McManus (St. Louis Browns)

Junior Gillam (Los Angeles Dodgers) vs Manny Trillo (Chicago Cubs)

 

I'll do the last two brackets later.

[RedRuffing15]

BRACKET ONE

Eddie Collins (Philadelphia Athletics) vs Ron Hunt (New York Mets)

Charlie Gehringer (Detroit Tigers) vs Johnny Temple (Cincinnati Reds)

Ryne Sandberg (Chicago Cubs) vs George Grantham (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Joe Gordon (New York Yankees) vs Dave Cash (Pittsburgh Pirates)*

Billy Herman (Chicago Cubs) vs Robby Thompson (San Francisco Giants)

Tony Lazzeri (New York Yankees) vs Davey Johnson (Baltimore Orioles)

Bill Mazeroski (Pittsburgh Pirates) vs Bobby Avila (Cleveland Guardians)

Hardy Richardson (Buffalo Bisons) vs Chuck Knoblauch (Minnesota Twins)

 

BRACKET TWO

Rogers Hornsby (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Glenn Beckert (Chicago Cubs)

Jackie Robinson (Brooklyn Dodgers) vs Danny Murphy (Philadelphia Athletics)

Frankie Frisch (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Claude Ritchey (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Larry Doyle (New York Giants) vs Jim Gantner (Milwaukee Brewers)

Nellie Fox (Chicago White Sox) vs Frank Bolling (Detroit Tigers)

Jeff Kent (San Francisco Giants) vs Phil Garner (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Davey Lopes (Los Angeles Dodgers) vs Gil McDougald (New York Yankees)

Miller Huggins (Cincinnati Reds) vs Kid Gleason (Philadelphia Phillies)

 

BRACKET THREE

Nap Lajoie (Cleveland Guardians) vs Felix Milan (Atlanta Braves)

Craig Biggio (Houston Astros) vs Tony Cuccinello (Boston Braves)

Lou Whitaker (Detroit Tigers) vs Fred Pfeffer (Chicago Cubs)

Willie Randolph (New York Yankees) vs Bobby Lowe (Boston Braves)

Johnny Evers (Chicago Cubs) vs Eddie Stanky (Brooklyn Dodgers)

Red Schoendienst (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Steve Sax (Los Angeles Dodgers)

Dick McAuliffe (Detroit Tigers) vs Lonny Frey (Cincinnati Reds)

Cupid Childs (Cleveland Spiders) vs Frank White (Kansas City Royals)

 

BRACKET FOUR

Joe Morgan (Houston Astros) vs Jimmy Williams (New York Yankees)

Roberto Alomar (Toronto Blue Jays) vs Tom Daly (Brooklyn Dodgers)

Bobby Grich (California Angels) vs Bill Doran (Cleveland Guardians)

Bobby Doerr (Boston Red Sox) vs Tony Taylor (Philadelphia Phillies)

Buddy Myer (Washington Senators) vs Max Bishop (Philadelphia Athletics)

Bid McPhee (Cincinnati Reds) vs Tom Herr (St. Louis Cardinals)

Del Pratt (St. Louis Browns) vs Marty McManus (St. Louis Browns)

Junior Gillam (Los Angeles Dodgers) vs Manny Trillo (Chicago Cubs)

 

**Went to my school, and holds every school record in Baseball and Basketball

[ORS]

I'm lazy, but the finals should be Morgan vs. Robinson.

[Matt]

BRACKET ONE

Eddie Collins (Philadelphia Athletics) vs Ron Hunt (New York Mets)

Charlie Gehringer (Detroit Tigers) vs Johnny Temple (Cincinnati Reds)

Ryne Sandberg (Chicago Cubs) vs George Grantham (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Joe Gordon (New York Yankees) vs Dave Cash (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Billy Herman (Chicago Cubs) vs Robby Thompson (San Francisco Giants)

Tony Lazzeri (New York Yankees) vs Davey Johnson (Baltimore Orioles)

Bill Mazeroski (Pittsburgh Pirates) vs Bobby Avila (Cleveland Guardians)

Hardy Richardson (Buffalo Bisons) vs Chuck Knoblauch (Minnesota Twins)

 

BRACKET TWO

Rogers Hornsby (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Glenn Beckert (Chicago Cubs)

Jackie Robinson (Brooklyn Dodgers) vs Danny Murphy (Philadelphia Athletics)

Frankie Frisch (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Claude Ritchey (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Larry Doyle (New York Giants) vs Jim Gantner (Milwaukee Brewers)

Nellie Fox (Chicago White Sox) vs Frank Bolling (Detroit Tigers)

Jeff Kent (San Francisco Giants) vs Phil Garner (Pittsburgh Pirates)

Davey Lopes (Los Angeles Dodgers) vs Gil McDougald (New York Yankees)

Miller Huggins (Cincinnati Reds) vs Kid Gleason (Philadelphia Phillies)

 

BRACKET THREE

Nap Lajoie (Cleveland Guardians) vs Felix Milan (Atlanta Braves)

Craig Biggio (Houston Astros) vs Tony Cuccinello (Boston Braves)

Lou Whitaker (Detroit Tigers) vs Fred Pfeffer (Chicago Cubs)

Willie Randolph (New York Yankees) vs Bobby Lowe (Boston Braves)

Johnny Evers (Chicago Cubs) vs Eddie Stanky (Brooklyn Dodgers)

Red Schoendienst (St. Louis Cardinals) vs Steve Sax (Los Angeles Dodgers)

Dick McAuliffe (Detroit Tigers) vs Lonny Frey (Cincinnati Reds)

Cupid Childs (Cleveland Spiders) vs Frank White (Kansas City Royals)

 

BRACKET FOUR

Joe Morgan (Houston Astros) vs Jimmy Williams (New York Yankees)

Roberto Alomar (Toronto Blue Jays) vs Tom Daly (Brooklyn Dodgers)

Bobby Grich (California Angels) vs Bill Doran (Cleveland Guardians)

Bobby Doerr (Boston Red Sox) vs Tony Taylor (Philadelphia Phillies)

Buddy Myer (Washington Senators) vs Max Bishop (Philadelphia Athletics)

Bid McPhee (Cincinnati Reds) vs Tom Herr (St. Louis Cardinals)

Del Pratt (St. Louis Browns) vs Marty McManus (St. Louis Browns)

Junior Gillam (Los Angeles Dodgers) vs Manny Trillo (Chicago Cubs)