Rank Your Top 5 Quarterbacks Of All Time

[schillingouttheks]

for me, it would be:

 

1. Elway

2. Montana

meh...could be Favre, Bradshaw and a ton of other people, i would have to normally wait for the end of favres career, but right now he is on absolute fire so my third is:

3. Favre

4. Dan Marino

5. Terry Bradshaw/Joe Namath-toss up

[papi4prez]

1. Favre

2. Elway

3. Marino

4. Montana

5. Bradshaw...

i would explain my picks but i dont have time...ill do it another time

[CrespoBlows]

1. Otto Grahamn

2. Sammy Baugh

3. Dan Marino

4. Joe Montana

5. Jon Elway

[YanksHater213]

My list is only of the time when I have followed football closely and have seen play which is like... a few years.

 

1. John Elway

2. Dan Marino

3. Brett Favre

4. Joe Montana

5. Peyton Manning

[BoSox Rule]

1. Joe Montana

2. Dan Mariano

3. Brett Favre

4. John Elway

5. Terry Bradshaw

 

If the Pats win the Super Bowl this year Brady probably moves up to 5 on my list.

[Yankeesin05]

Brady? top 5? No he isn't carrying his team

[schillingouttheks]

brady is what sparks this team. hes the straw that stirs the drink...

 

brady carried this team on his shoulders for 2 superbowl seasons in 3 years, and is en route for another....

 

i will admit the addition of dillon has helped, but brady has led the pats to 50-13 in his starts.

 

however, i do agree with yankeesin05 that he is not top 5, i think hes close. top 10, maybe 9th or 10th spot.

[Yankeesin05]

Where would you guys put Vick? (in terms of potential)

[schmidtybonds]

1. Montana: 4 superbowls, beat elway and marino

2. Unitas

3. Elway

4. Marino

5. Favre

[element1151]

Originally posted by Yankeesin05@Dec 8 2004, 04:17 PM

Brady? top 5? No he isn't carrying his team

He said if they win this year, that would be 3 Super Bowls for him, that had to be close to if not #5.

[schillingouttheks]

i said about 7, 8 or 9. 3 superbowls in 4 years at about 24 years old (?) is amazing...with a great future ahead. he could easily develop into a top 5 QB, but im not sure...its pretty damn hard. and to answer someones Q about vick, hed go in the early 20s for me...not good enough yet, was hurt whole last year, had one good year, having a goood year, but before i make my decision, id want to see more of his west coast offense skills.