Bloom's shortstop debacle may be the defining issue of his ultimate failure as CBO in Boston. When it comes to the most important non-battery position on the diamond, there can be no plans A-B-C-D when they all turn out to be Fs.
If he originally signed Story as an intended half-price replacement for Bogaerts, management must have known the elbow was in doubt. Maybe this was acknowledged by not trading X at the deadline, and then calling him the club's priority last fall. Also, second base looked more suitable for Story's future.
But once the Sox lost both Bogie and Story -- many options of actual Major League shortstops were still available, from high-priced stars to inexpensive gloves. Instead, Bloom acquired more damaged goods in Mondesi, and now we have Kike on pace to commit 80 errors at short. Enough with getting guys who aren't ready to help (it only worked with Schwarber because his best position was in the batter's box; we're still waiting on Paxton, two years later.)
As Boston fades into summer with this suspect defense, maybe the only way for Bloom to save his job will be to promote Marcelo Mayer and let him Volpe (or Casas) his way through the bigs...