Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Hugh2

Old-Timey Member
  • Posts

    4,534
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    8

 Content Type 

Profiles

Boston Red Sox Videos

2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospect Rankings

Boston Red Sox Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Boston Red Sox Fan Guides & Resources

2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Boston Red Sox News, Rumors & Analysis

2026 Boston Red Sox Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Hugh2

  1. You're not getting an ACE for QTY, I feel like this debate was had over at BDC every year. Those types of trades never happen. Qty does not make up for quality, the other team isn't living in a world where the Redsox can figure out how to not give up Bogaerts Betts, and if the situation dictates a prospect package you better believe you're giving up 2 of Devers, Benintendi, Espinoza, Moncada plus two from your list.
  2. No we wouldn't, if anything Benintendi is more heralded as an up the middle defender and Bogaerts was considered an offense first SS. This is 2016 and you have google, it's not a secret. When Bogaerts was at this stage of his development he was younger than Benintendi and the #2 prospect in all of baseball. Benintendi is a really really really highly regarded prospect but 2013 Bogaerts > 2016 Benintendi all day. Andrew has the #7 pick expectations that never came with Xander. If a 20 year old Xander entered the draft as an eligible sophomore I think he'd be a consensus #1 pick.
  3. Has there ever been a 6 or 7 player swap for one guy? I dont' think we can make up for quality with QTY. If you want a high quality player you have to give up quality. Trades are supposed to hurt for both teams, the other side has to think they are winning the trade.
  4. Of course this is assuming that the Mets want the trade off of hitting for pitching. They might not want that, and they might want to move prospects for hitting to keep their pitching core in tact.
  5. Young cost controlled ace starters on teams that are in "win now" mode don't get traded. The only way this is plausible is if the Mets think they can trade off pitching for hitting in which case they are 100% going to demand back MLB talent. In other words, a guy like Bogaerts is going to have to headline the trade. Now a prospect package might be feasible on a last place team but not for a team that was just in the world series last year and has aspirations to compete going forward. I think something like Bogaerts/Devers/Owens/Buchholz gets it done.
  6. Planet earth.
  7. Because some people got it in there heads Young was horrible after a few games because they like to look at things like BA, he will be hated for a long time I forsee. I suppose if the team is so good all you can complain about is the platoon/4th outfielder then things must be going pretty good.
  8. At this point in the 2013 season Bogaerts was in Portland, but he had 100 games under his belt...not 3. Also I think Bogaerts had/has a higher offensive ceiling than someone like Benintendi who is more of a moderately high ceiling high floor guy. I'm not saying he can't do it, but if he's going to be there in October he has to be there in August and we are assuming he's going to jump 2 more levels in 2 months after only playing 3 games above A ball.
  9. This is a very accurate assessment in my opinion. While I definitely see a path for him to the majors this year my money would be against it.
  10. When Benintendi gets promoted to Boston later this year we should title a thread with the wording "And now his watch begins"
  11. He's MLB ready!!! Promote him now!!!
  12. Like I said, BABIP can be a skill...but I highly doubt half the team is going to BABIP close to .400 the whole year. Hard contact, good contact, and hitting line drives can definitely increase your BABIP over the long run but even then it's very hard to maintain those numbers. Think of it this way.....those 4 guys have a higher average on balls in play of close to .100 than David Ortiz. If they do keep this up then we could have a close to a historic season offensively on our hands and we will all be salivating at the mouth with joy come October. Which I hope to be doing.
  13. Nope, we don't. I never said Sam Travis has to be that guy only that he isn't....and that should be fine on a well constructed team. If the overall offense is great all around why go out and spend $20 million plus on a first baseman? I get that it's relatively an easy position to fill and it's ideal to put a big bopper there but everything is relative and I think it could certainly make sense to have a guy like Sam Travis (assuming he can do in MLB what he's done in the minors) at first base. And who knows....maybe he does grow into a little bit more power.
  14. He's a 27 year old with poor defense and a MiLB track record at AAA for about 5 seasons. He could OPS 1.000 right now and his trade value wouldn't be much more than what it is now.
  15. I like Sam Travis bat a lot, there is definitely a MLB hitter in there but I don't think his power is ever going to be what people expect it to be. He hits the ball very hard but he just doesn't have a HR swing, he's a line drive guy and he's hit at least 3 laser shot HR's this year that would easily be wall ball singles at Fenway. There's nothing wrong with that and he is going to be valuable but I just don't see a perennial 30/100 guy in him like a Goldschmidt or an Ortiz. Now, he could be the rare type that is able to make some adjustments and alter his swing to add power to his game but that seems to flame more guys out and create more busts than it helps (Think Garrin Cecchini). Honestly I'd be fine with what Sam Travis potentially will bring to the big leagues. I think he can be a .280 hitter .800 OPS guy with about 12-15 HR's.
  16. He's a Buuuuuuuum. I can't believe we wasted the #7 pick on him. Who is going to play LF in August now???
  17. I think if you focus on trying to replace Ortiz with one person at DH you're going to spend a ton of money for one position for a guy who doesnt' play the field and nothing on pitching. I think the reality is you can't replace a guy like Ortiz. You focus on putting together a good all around baseball team and if you do that you won't need to replace Ortiz.
  18. 25% K rate 0% B rate. He's batting .000/.000/.000 with zero power. Obviously the Sox have rushed him.
  19. Bust!!!!!!!!!!!
  20. Kelly should get the nod before Erod.
  21. Trey Ball had a good night. 6 1/3 innings with 10 K's. 5 hits and 2 BB's. Four of the hits were singles and he had 4/1 GO/FO. Also reportedly his velocity has returned this spring as well. I still haven't given up on Ball developing into a good middle of the rotation starter.
  22. Yes, I did say I still think this is one of the leagues best offenses. But when the Sox come back down to earth (and still have a really really really good offense) the pitching will be exposed. Of course, that might somewhat be apparent now.
  23. I agree, BABIP can be a skill to an extent. If you are hitting more line drives and making harder contact you will have a higher BABIP. Some players always have BABIP above .300. I tend to put more weight into BABIP in terms to a players own large sample size. Still....I expect some type of regression.
  24. BABIP Travis Shaw .398 Hanley Ramirez .396 Jackie Bradley Jr. .390 Xander Bogaerts .389 ....sorry. P.S. I still think this is going to be one of the best offenses all year, and I still think all those guys will be good. But a regression is coming.
  25. Joshua Ockimey is a guy I've had my eye on and he was my sleeper candidate over the winter as well. The K rate would normally concern me but 23% isn't really all that concerning when it's matched with a high average, power, and a walk rate that is almost comparable 20%. Still given his age and the fact that this is his first taste of success I could see the Sox keeping him in Greenville all year but I don't think they will. He's probably a guy that could move up at the end of the year. Perhaps sooner, I could see him getting promoted to Salem when Longhi goes up to Portland if he keeps raking as well.
×
×
  • Create New...