Yes, that is a significant factor, but to me, underperformance by our higher paid players is number 1 on my list of reasons we can't get beyond .500 or sniff the playoffs. Granted $10M/1 is not a "big contract," but those have been among the top 10 on the team over the last few years.
While we had way more higher paid players in 2019, the underperformances began, then:
(Note: while a $4M deal is not "big," i included all deals of $4 or more to show the shifts from large to medium and sub medium. The line demarks the top 10 salaries, each year)
Red= Underperformed, injured or both
31 Price 22 GS 4.28
22 JD
21 Porcello 5.52 ERA
20 Betts
17 Nate 12 GS 5.99
14 Pedey 21 PAs
15 Sale 25 GS 4.40
12 Bogey
9 JBJ
7 Moreland
6 Pearce 99 PAs .503 OPS
6 Vaz
5 Nunez 174 PAs .548 OPS
4 ERod/Holt
2020 was when the full throttle purge began, but injuries and declines continued:
26 Sale No show
22 JD .680
20 Bogey
17 Nate Made 9 of 12 starts
14 Pedey No show
11 JBJ
8 E Rod No show
7 Perez 4.50 not really underperforming exp's.
5 Beni only 52 PAs .442
5 Vaz
4 Pillar (Traded)
4 Workman (Traded for Pivetta)
2021 saw some improved health and bounce back years:
25 Sale 9GS
22 JD
20 Bogey
17 Nate
10 Richards 22 GS 4.87 demoted to pen
9 Ottavino 4.21 was not much below expectations
8 ERod 4.74 ERA is high for him
7 Kike
5 Perez 4.74 about as expected
5 Barnes Fell apart last 2 months
5 Vaz .659
5 Devers
2022 brought the Story contract and the $5-10M one deals:
26 Sale 2GS
23 Story
22 JD .790 & 74 RBI
20 Bogey 73 RBI
17 Nate
12 JBJ .578
11 Devers
10 Paxton No show
9 Barnes 4.31
7 Kike
7 Vaz
7 Wacha 23 GS about expected, but pitched well
5 Hill 26 GS and 4.27 ERA
2023 was the questionable choice to stay over $16M under the tax line.
26 Sale 20 GS 4.30
23 Story 168 PAs .566
18 Devers
18 Yoshida .783 not horrible, but...
16 Jansen
11 Turner
10 Kike 323 PAs .599 (Traded)
10 Kluber 9GS 7.07
9 Barnes + Blier ugly
8 Martin
7 Duvall Just 353 PAs but did well
6 Verdugo A bit of a let down but kept in black (balanced Duvall)
5 Pivetta
4 Paxton 19 GS 4.50 (had a nice stretch)
2024: the inexplicable further cuts to the budget.
Jury is out on some, but we know some are toasted)
29 Devers
23 Story Out
19 Gio Out
18 Yoshida To late to redeem
16 Jansen ???
9 Bello So far, a letdown
8 Martin So far, a letdown
8 Pivetta Missed some time
6 O'Neill Missed some time
5 Hendriks Out until AUG
5 Whitlock Out
(None between 2.1 and 4.6)
The RED really shows the #1 issue.
By year in RED:
5 of top 7 '19
7 of top 9 '20 worst year
4 of top 7 '21 best record in 5 years and least RED (4 in top 10)
8 out of 10 '22
6 out of 9 '23
3 out of top 4, already