I'm a Swihart supporter. I want him on the playoff roster, something some don't want.
I'm also a Vaz and Leon supporter, and I think many are overlooking the fact that he had a couple bad months and was doing very well, before he got hurt. Swihart had a very hot month and has sucked at the plate every other month, including two months with about the same PAs as his hot July month.
I do see Swihart as a better hitter and with more offensive upside going forward.
I think we should have all 3 on the playoff roster, so we can afford to PH for a catcher or two. We will not need to PH for any other position, except maybe Pearce for Moreland or Moreland for Pearce at 1B.