I have not denied that his stats are mostly fueled by 1 streak or two each season, in fact, I mentioned it.
Yes, I'd prefer a more consistent hitter.
Yes, I'd prefer he not swing for the fences every PA.
He is what he is, and I don't understand a lot of his thinking and approach, but the fact is, he ends up around .730-.830 jest about every year since his horrendous start in the bigs.
Streaky hitters still contribute. It's just all bunched up in short time frames.
I wish he was more consistent, and maybe someday he'll figure out what he's doing wrong during his cold stretches and adjust more quickly.
The fact that, overall, he's hit the ball as hard as Betts since 2015 kind of surprised me. That can't all come from 2 months each season, can it? Maybe I'm wrong, but I do feel like he's had some bad luck during some of his cold streaks. His BAbip since from 2015-2016 was .312. From 2017 to 2018 it has been .282. it's .255 this year, despite the high hard hit ball % that has remained pretty consistently around 36% every year.
I know his plate discipline and lack of adjustments is a big part of his problems, but it doesn't negate the fact that he hits the ball hard and often gets nothing to show for it.
The shift has a lot to do with that, and if he learned how to bunt or go the other way, those numbers would probably change to the good.