Who is saying Bloom's building of a MLB roster a success?
I don't think it is "pathetic" to say our ML roster might be as good as or better than Philly's or some other teams with slightly better records, who happen to play in easier divisions and or have easier or much easier schedules.
Yes, Bloom's job is to build a better team than at least 3 other ALE teams, in order to have a real shot at the playoffs. He's done it once in 3 years, and I'm not counting 2020. He has not been a success, in this way, but one can easily argue, he has built 2 or maybe 3 teams (2021 and 2023 and maybe '22) that were pretty good and might have made the playoffs by merely being placed in another division, I don't see that as "bad luck." Bad luck, to me, is having more injuries than other teams from players not viewed as injury prone, of getting bad calls by umps, or the sun was in Verdugo's eyes- that kind of thing.
One can argue we have not been as good or better than Philly, Minnesota, the Cubs or several other teams, despite not being "successful."
I brought up the DD- Bloom comp a couple days ago to show how similar the teams have been, but how wildly differently they are viewed due to a situation totally out of anybody on the Sox control. It's not excuse making. It's not proclaiming Bloom is a success. On 26 man roster construction, he has not been that. I have yet to hear one person say that, but there is a legion of posters who pretend there is a posse of posters who think Bloom shits gold bars.