A short update--revisiting the thread topic--based on two recent events. The first of course is that insane thread arguing that Ortiz should be the manager. I'm happy to say the idea is not getting much support.
The second event is the now concluded 2 game sweep of the Cardinals--NL Central leaders--in St Louis. To me that series suggests this team just might be better than I thought because I thought both wins were gritty. Last night's 13 inning, 4 1/2 hour monster required Farrell to use 12 of his 13 position players and 9 of his 12 pitchers. All to good effect: after giving up 4 early runs, Porcello pitched 4 scoreless innings and a total of 6 before Farrell brought in 8 relievers who held the Cardinals scoreless for 7 innings. So, yes, I think Farrell did a good job.
But my real point is that the players overall were great in this series. They won two close games on the road against a good team with very good pitching. In the second game, they came from behind (4-0) to finally tie the game in the 8th on that magnificent triple by Bogaerts followed by a gritty sac fly by Benintendi, who is in a terrible slump (0 for 26) but rose to the occasion. Moreland made a really dumb play on a bunt to enable the early Cardinals rally, but hit that double in 13th and scored the winning run on Young's pinch hit single. Zowie.
Last year the Sox finished the season with 6 of the top 32 hitters--defined solely by their OPS's--in the American League: Ortiz, Betts, HanRam, Pedroia, Bogaerts, and JBJ. Right now we have 2 of the top 32, Betts and Bogaerts. Yes, we lost Ortiz, but the other 5 are back, and for the first month this year Benintendi had a high OPS. I think most of us believe Benintendi's slump will not last.
My point is the same one Kimmi and others have made--this team should be able to hit and probably will hit this year. When they do, this can be a good team despite my periodic rants about lousy defense (Marrero has fixed the 3B problem, and everyone else is decent and Betts is terrific), lousy baserunning, etc. Assuming Price comes back and in decent form, that's four pretty darn good starters: Sale, Porcello, Price, and ERod. The bullpen, with occasional lapses, has been pretty good too. I personally dislike Pomeranz, but I have seen far worse 5th starters.
So my other point is that just maybe Farrell has been managing well under trying circumstances and that it makes sense for DD to keep him around.