No, Theo was not an idiot here; he did not suck in terms of overall performance. His area of success, or at least the area where his management team succeeded, was in developing young players like Pedroia, Lester, and Ellsbury, among others. However, his list of failures in the free agency arena reads like a bad novel. He gets an "F" in this area. Overall, I would grade him a "C". Not a total failure, but not someone I would want as GM for my ML team.