Actually this is where we disagree. This is something like the "September was an anomaly" argument. I say something like because I don't have the right to try to do a vulcan mind meld and know for sure where this argument is coming from. However, they are absolutely not 110% of what they need to be to go all the way primarily because they do not have the starting pitching to do that. This is going to be two years running that they will have buried the pen. The pen already has the white flag of surrender up as we speak in early August for heavens sake. We need a legitimate Ace, a true 1 which may also help us bring back Lester along with a new pitching coach. A legit 1 with Buch, Felix, Frank and possibly a rejuvenated Lester and Lackey (God help me) might be enough starting pitching to get you there. Any combination of the guys they have now simply won't get it done nor will dumping another guy in the 3 hole.
As for Ortiz, I only give Ortiz his two year deal if he is fully committed to being the kind of leader that he says he is and that I need him to be. If not...he gets a one year deal and thats that. I might even be willing to go two years and a team option for a third if that gets me the guy I want Ortiz to be. That way I control a third year that I could give him if he is a good boy.
But there is no way that I can conceive of using Ortiz to get me a legit pitcher and I need his bat, the former being more of an issue than the latter. I can with Pedey and I just can't with anybody else other than buckets of guys like Bradley, Bradley being an excellent example for why I can't do that either.