The elements of victory mentioned are as described by 700 and jacko. Although Buch went down for an extended period, Lackey the ultimate wild card really balanced out the scales of justice with an unexpectedly solid season long performance considering his TJ. Combine that with Felix and his 15 straight starts giving up fewer than 3 runs, the addition of Peavey and even to some extent, Demps and the starting pitching was a huge plus even with Buch sitting out 3 months. Biggest element....Lackey's performance which nobody would have projected giving the 1st year back from TJ track record for ML pitchers, followed by Peavey's impact both real on the mound and apparently perceived by his rotation mates.
The other two major elements:
The Sox process for generating offense.....really could not have foreseen this Sox team fielding the most disciplined offense in baseball, not only 1-9 but 1-12 when you consider the bench players also falling right in step. 1,000 more pitches seen than the next best team mark in baseball???? You have got to be kidding me! Not convinced that even the Sox themselves could ever be that disciplined again as a team over the 162...an amazing performance by this group of players and in fact the only path they had to producing this much offense. You can only hope that your whole will be greater than the sum of its parts. You can't predict it.
and,
Ueh..... had both Hanrahan and Bailey not gone down, this year's best closer in baseball would not have closed a single game for the Sox. I don't believe that even Hanrahan/Bailey together would have produced what Ueh has produced closing games. However I do think they would have done just good enough to have kept Ueh from floating to the top.
I don't at all believe that this season was a matter of luck as one of the thread starters here (troll) claims and posted. You make your own luck anyway. However the things that made this season for the Sox were truly unpredictable.
To me, the players themselves both individually and as a group deserve the lions share of the credit for this regular season performance, followed by the FO and even upper management and then the coaching staff.