When they let Bregaman walk and didn't sign another elite bat, all the responsibility by definition went to Anthony, whether it was said or not. It's called logic. Let's not fool ourselves, Duran and Abreu are not supposed to be at the same tier as Anthony will, at least not on paper. Anthony is supposed to be the face of the franchise, period. Heck, Abreu and Duran were trade chips not long ago. Anthony? He's Boston's Holy Grail! The real question was, Is he going to smash the ball this early of his life? The FO made it clear, and said Yes; again, when they didn't sign another elite bat to protect him. Said that, yeah, I still believe he's going to bounce back but for now, he has officially entered into my book of concerns, mostly regarding his glove and durability. Time will tell though,
Regarding Duran and using your same geek logic, isn't he hitting the ball hard? What does StatCasts say? I haven't checked out but I would bet his BABIP is below league's average. Duran's problems are different though. He still has mental issues IMO.