I knew it, something was wrong with Peddy, Dammit... I mentioned that Peddy was hurting this team offensively lately and mostly with his bat, and now i got the answer... something was happening, that BA wasn't a slump strictly by performance or AB discipline but by injury.
Looking at overall career's numbers, there's no way that CC could take 1-5 spot, but being fair, last month he has the numbers in order to at least give him a shot... and yeah, you have a point here, he's not a rookie that got a short fluke streak... now with Peddy's issue , CC should take that shot and show that he deserves that spot or at least compete for it.