Those LWs are Rs expectancies for those situations, but in the end based on a model, to predict those Rs, right?, so... in order to rest your case, here the facts:
In 162 games, CC has 99 Rs, 102 SB and 38 BB and Peddy has 108 Rs, 59 SB, 67 BB
In 162 games, CC(Rs)-P(Rs)=9 Rs, Coincidence?... This guy is right!, another way to probe that CC has no room in the 1-2 spot.
EDIT: 2011: CC(Rbat) -9, P(Rbat) -2. CC(Rbaser) 0, P(Rbaser) 2... nothing else to say!