So let's say that Lester and Beckett return and throw consistent with their FIP's. And Buchholz continues to throw to his 3.35 era like he had for his past 8 starts.
Those aren't outrageous projections by any means. You are telling me that you are so against this teams chances that you wouldnt want Crawford to be in LF in the event that we have a 1 game playoff against, say, the Angels? Or are you so sold on the fact that a 2.5 game deficit is just an unbearable amount of games to overcome? Do you truly think that with Ellsbury, Pedroia, and Crawford at the top of the order, the Orioles, Tigers, A's, Rays, and Angels are so much better that the Sox can't pick up 2 or 3 games on them?
Now, I assume you agree that this team is capable of making a WC slot, but you don't like the odds of winning a WC game because of our pitchers. Well, let's take another look at how Crawford does against other teams aces.
Angels: Weaver: .333/.333/.600
Tigers: Verlander: .310/.310/.310
Guardians: Masterson: .267/.333/.667
Rays: Price: 0-9
Orioles: Not gonna happen, but Crawford hasn't faced Hammel.
Point being, if the Sox make the 2nd wild card, there's a very good chance that Crawford can play a big role in that WC game. So why the heck wouldn't we wait and at least give our best shot to win this year? Because you want Crawford to be back in January?!? That makes zero sense.