9 All-star nominations, 5 top-five MVP nominations and a top-10 mvp nomination. 6 silver sluggers, 3 rings, two RBI titles, a HR title two walk titles, an OBP title.
Over the years Ortiz was active, you will only find a handful of his contemporaries who have put up numbers as consistent as his. Pujols, Cabrera, Holliday, Fielder, Guerrero. The list of guys with his level of production at the plate is not very long -- especially in the post-steroid era of drug testing and such.
It really just depends on how voters look at the drugs that he may have taken.