My favorite season in recent memory (not including this one) was 2010... and while it probably isn't all that important, per say, that was the cornerstone season that this one is so similar to.
That was the year Pedroia broke his foot, and was trying to keep in shape by taking balls in the field from his knees. The stars like Youkilis, Beckett, Lowell, Papelbon, Ellsbury and Ortiz had either been hurt or underperforming all season.
It was a season about the non-stars. Daniel Nava's grand slam "was a great moment in what would be a very short major league career". Some of us had Darnell Mcdonald-mania, while others had "DFA DARNELL!" . Scott Atchison was the 7th inning guy, and bridge to Bard+Pap. Lackey toughed out quality start after quality start, and we never heard the end of bitching about him. Jed Lowrie had a .907 OPS, and earned the nickname "The Sexy Beast", and Scutaro was playing the field with a dislodged vertebrae. Every single player contributed, and there was always some 4A guy surprising us all with an amazing performance. It wasn't a year for pink hats... it was a year for baseball fans.