I just don't think the Yankees can keep bleeding stars. Last year, Posada, Swisher, Martin, and others. This year, Pettite, Rivera. Maybe Granderson, Kuroda, A-rod, Cano. The talent just isn't out there on the free agent market to replace those guys.
After next year, Jeter's gone. The Yankees will have to re-sign Robertson and Gardner, and those guys may very well get 15M AAV. Outside of Nova, the entire team will be mercenaries. The casual fans are going to get lost in the shuffle.