The Sox can not afford to continue starting Drew if he does not come around very soon. He remains the best defensive option at SS the Sox have but his value there is negated by his putrid performance at the plate. I still think that with the luxury of about 60-80 AB in Pawtucket Drew would have been better prepared to actually get hits and not strike out so much. But for some reason ( as I said on another thread, most likely a Boras / Drew refusal or a contract clause ) the decision was made to have him start with only a handful of at bats prior to being brought up. This was really stupid. They had to know that he was not ready yet.
Again, I don't believe the move to 3rd base is the cause of X's misfortunes at the plate. It may have shaken him some, but I believe that he is just slumping and or pitchers know what to throw to him and he has not adjusted yet. This is what many rookies go through. I have hope and faith that whatever position he is playing that he will figure it out and start to hit again. Maybe we all just expected too much from the kid in the first place?
Strangely, throughout this mess, Herrera seems to have played well both defensively and offensively. Maybe the Sox should play him more often.
I have zero hope or faith that either Middlebrooks or Victorino will contribute to a resurgence this year.
I've been one of those who advocated giving WMB the job at 3rd this year to finally see if he has learned how to hit consistently in the majors. Mostly because I realize how bereft the Sox organization is of power hitters. His 32 HR in about 600 PA were and remain tantalizing. But, he is continually doing nothing to contribute because of one thing or another. I've lost patience with him almost entirely. I say move on without him at the 3rd.
I, like a700, have seen Victorino play CF many times in the NL. I agree that he WAS a great defensive player at that position THEN. Now he can not even run to first base without tweaking a hammy. I keep saying this. Hamstring injuries usually never go away. His game was largely dependent on speed and bursts of speed. I do not think that he will ever be capable of this again. The Sox should plan on not having him full time this season.
I still like his game when he is healthy, though.