For the record ( since you came on board after I said my pieces regarding how the should be built, what they did wrong, and predicted 3-4 place ) I never expected this team to sniff the playoffs this year. I do agree that there is talent on this team. Especially with the position players.
Talent is not enough. I think that along with a lousy pitching staff, this team has too many players of questionable character. Not enough heart.
Overall, this team just does not have enough of anything to be a playoff team regardless of whether the team construction was a good idea / poor execution or not. The entire org fell miserably short of anything that should have been reasonably expected for a team of such resources.
As usual, this is just my opinion. People can say what they want about how Fat Boy and the Dredded One have underperformed. That is a cop out. I'd much rather have Gomes / Nava in left and WMB at 3rd now. I never once thought that those guys were not giving their best.
I can not say with any real certainty or even conviction where the disconnect is. But I say the cream is sour at the top.