When comparing the teams, I like Kilo's offense better, but I like Y228's defense better. Unlike the other semifinal, I see this being a lower scoring game. I think that Kilo has the better QB, and WRs, while Y228 has the better RB tandem, TE, and I consider the offensive lines to be pretty even. I think that Kilo got lucky when he decided to take a RB late because I think it's generally a poor strategy, but it worked out in the end. However, I don't like McGahee as a backup back because he lacks an explosive in space back. I think that Y228 did the better job of pairing backs with a grinder up the middle and an explosive screen back. So I think that Kilo has the best back of the 4, but that Y228 would get the rushing advantage for the pair.
I think that little needs to be said about Brady vs. Rodgers. I think that Brady is better overall, and Rodgers can run the ball better, but isn't as accurate and pinpoint a passer as Brady. I think Kilo has very good WR's, we'll disagree all day about who's WR set is better, but I like his over most other teams. I think it was too early to pick Hernandez and I like Cooley as a better all around TE.
The defense in my opinion is what's going to decide this. Kilo committed a cardinal sin of putting a 4-3 DE into a 3-4 spot. Never, should you EVER do that. I think that Cameron Wake is very underrated (although Yahoo lists him as a linebacker for some reason) and although he isn't as big as a typical 3-4 DE, I don't see that being a huge problem because of his speed. Haloti Ngata is also one of the best DT's, so Kilo has a decent Dline overall, although he f***** himself by choosing Long.
In addition, 2 of Kilo's linebackers (Greenway and Vilma) are out of position. Granted, both of them are 4-3 linebackers being put into a 3-4, so their jobs should be easier, however, one specific example of this backfiring is with Vilma himself, who did much better in a 4-3 MLB role than a 3-4. He's even stated that he hated the 3-4 in New York. To make sure, I had a few Jets friends confirm it.
Anyway, as for Y228's defense, the only front 7 player out of position is Lofton, and he's also a 4-3 MLB being put into a 3-4 defense. I think he has a better front 7 overall, and Kilo's positional sins ice it up. I also like Y228's secondary better than Kilo's as well. I think that Corey Webster is an ok CB, not bad, but not good enough to be a #1 corner in this league. The only member of Kilo's secondary that's really good is Nick Collins. I'd take Y228 at the other spots.
The kickers are close, Neil Rackers career percentage is .6% better, but I won't hold that against Kilo. Granted, Rackers past 3 years have been much higher than Janikowski's, but I'm not going to let it decide the match.
Y228's punter has a little better numbers than Kilo's as well, which I consider to be a small detail, in addition, I like Y228's kick returner (Leon Washington) better, but Mccluster has a better role in Kilo's offense.
For coaching sake, I wasn't a fan of Kilo's choice. I think Capers is a good guy and he's knowledgable, but it seemed like a showboating and unnecessary move. I'd take Coughlin over him at the moment.
Anyway, no secret here, I like Kilo's offense and Y228's defense. This is one of the few times where I think that Tom Brady can be beaten. He's going to have a hard time keeping up with how many points his defense will give up to Y228's offense. I see Brady having to drop back a lot, due to Y228's better front 7, and the fact that I think Kilo's team will be trailing and running uphill. I think that Y228 has the running backs to ice the game better than Kilo's, and in a neutral field, I'd take Y228's team by 4-7 points.
I'd predict Y228: 24 Kilo: 20