I honestly think Oakland was a fluke.
Think about it, massive stadium, uber-weak lineup. Yet the guy still got on base at a near-elite clip.
Holliday + Green Monster= WIN.
Of the two teams, which did he leave on bad terms?
And i don't wanna hear about that now, even if it was the Yankees on the ugly end. Maybe just my opinion.
If he's no longer the player he was, and that is a show-stopper, and is basically the smallest of the Big 3, how is he not in the twilight of his career?