And Delcarmen, for that matter.
Here's a startling thought -- what do Kevin Youkilis, Dustin Pedroia, and Jed Lowrie have in common?
Three things.
1: they are eassily the three most successful homegrown position players of the Theo Epstein era
2: Each one had significant concerns about their performance that held them in AAA longer than perhaps was absolutely necessary (Pedroia, conditioning and swing mechanics, Youkilis, power, Lowrie, defensive range) and
3: becaise of those doubts they were held back until they proved they had overcome those difficulties. (Pedroia could have had the job in 2006, possibly, except that he showed up to camp out of shape, we all know the story with Youkilis, and Lowrie is still working to establish this)
The amazing thing about this is that Boston's archconservatism when it comes to promoting young position players has resulted in a stable cadre of very solid young players coming up and definitely being ready from the moment they arrived.
Contrast this to how they've handled young pitchers. Hansen, Delcarmen, Lester, Buchholz Masterson, and Papelbon were all in a sense rushed. None of them really saw all that much AAA time before their first MLB taste and if Masterson in particular is stretched back out into a starter his next injury rehab will be more time in AAA than he's seen thus far.
We got lucky with Papelbon and Masterson, and Lester eventually worked through his issues despite some extra adversity, but Hansen, MDC and Buchholz are all struggling, at the major league level, with issues the position-player parallel of which would have held them in AA or AAA until they sorted it out there.
What I'd love to see is some of that vaunted conservatism that has helped shape successful beginnings to the careers of Youk, Dusty, and Jed, translated to the other side of the ballgame and put to good use as a pitcher-development philosophy. Unfortunately, though, the Red Sox got lucky a few times early on in this wave of player development, especially with Papelbon, so I'm not sure it's going to happen that way.