Aaron Hill. .296 avg, .335 OBP, .495 SLG, .830 OPS, 20HR, 59 RBI (368 Atbats)
or
Ben Zobrist. .282 avg, .404 OBP, .595 SLG, .998 OPS, 16HR, 46 RBI (227 Atbats)
I would also have picked Kinsler, Cano, and Roberts over Pedroia. It just goes to show that the All-star voting is a popularity contest.