One of the must talk about subject this Winter among Red Sox fans is who will play short stop in 2007. Before we discuss Gonzalez and Lugo, we know who won't be regular and that will be Dustin Pedroia or Alex Cora while both should be on the 07 roster neither has the range or arm to a short stop for a contending team.
It has been reported that in order to sign Julio Lugo it will take a multi year contract about 8 to 9 million per year. Lugo is mainly an offensive Shortstop one who could hit for a high average, that will score a lot runs, who has very good speed and will steal bases, one who has gap power, but not Home run power. With the glove is an average shorstop one who has an OK range and arm, but one who is very capable of comiting 30 errors in a season or one who will cost a game like he did a few years ago with the Astros when in the playoffs he cost them a couple games before the Astros bench him for the rest of the playoff.
It has been talk about that Alex Gonzalez wants a multiple years contract. In my opinion Gonzalez would sign a contract for two years around the 4.5 millions per year plus a option for the third year. Anyone who has seen Gonzalez play the last few years will know that he is capable of making the routine play and the spectecular one, very few Shortstop (if any) has the range that he does and none one turns the DP as well as he does. As a hitter we all know that he doesn't make as much contact as we will like, that he has average speed, but he is capable of hitting 15-20 HR (if he plays 150 games) and can drive in some runs.
In conclusion when an organization looks for shortstop it looks for one that will give a top defense, one who could make the routine play and has the range and arm, one who won't cost you a game with his glove, one that what he gives you with his bat will be frosting, not one that you depends in his bat. The Sox needs more offense production we all know that, but they needed from a production positions like first base, that is why they need a change at first base and the answer who should be the Red Sox shortstop for 2007 is Ales Gonzalez not Julio Lugo.