You don't watch our team like we do. First of all, give me their team over the last 11 years and I would have probably won 4 championships myself.
My knock on Torre, and always has been, his mismanagement of the bullpen.
It's one thing if you are losing, or in a tied game. However, he takes his starting pitchers out when they have a 3 run lead in the sixth inning. It is precisely those games that costs the Yankees the tight games.
For example: Matsuzaka has not been good against the Yankees. He has just pitched better than his Yankee counterparts. As long as he had a lead, Francona kept him in, saved his bullpen for the next day. If Torre had a 5-2 lead in the 6th with Pettitte on the hill against Matsuzaka, he takes him out and brings in the bullpen. Roles reversed, Francona keeps Matsuzaka in. How hard is it to manage when you had Mendoza, followed by Stanton and Nelson, and then Rivera to shut the door, all in their prime years? The Yankees of the late nineties didn't need a manager, they needed a scorekeeper.
Torre hasn't realized one thing in ALL the years of managing.
Your bullpen is most effective if it stays in the bullpen.