If it's true, then we will both be unhappy. The Yankees will never win another World Series under Cashman's watch. Period. His experiment with young pitching when superstar pitchers were available cost them a potential world series victory, and by the time he realizes his mistake, the window of opportunity with the players he has [Arod, Damon, etc] will be gone. He will forever be the dog that chases his tail. The Red Sox have passed them, and soon, the Rays/Red Sox rivalry will be the one to watch. With Cashman at the helm, we will be looking at the dark ages of the early 90's all over again.
If this is true, this is the worst day in recent Yankee history.
The question is...are you happy? Are you happy with a GM that under his watch has drafted ONE significant player in Chamberlain? That since he took over in the 90's, ten years or so ago, he has drafted ONE impact player? The same guy who picked Pavano over Pedro, Igawa over Lilly, Hawkins over Mahay? The one who didn't trade Melky and Kennedy for Santana?
Look, nothing would make me happier than if Hughes, Kennedy, and Chamberlain had the Yankees in first place this year, and everyone was touting this triumvariete [sp?] as the next Maddux, Glavine, and Smoltz. However, his talent evaluation in the free agent market is piss-poor. His drafting is piss-poor. He makes good deadline deals because his team can absorb salary. Any idiot can make the Abreu deal, or the Nady deal. When it comes to allocating your team's funds in the off-season, he's lost. When it comes to predicting which players will do well, and which ones will not, he's at the bottom of the list as GMs.
I have no problem with young players coming up who are good. He doesn't know how to identify them, draft them, or trade them away. He can't sign free agent pitchers to save his life.
So the question is...are you happy, and why?