Here goes....
1. Sign Grady Sizemore to a 1 yr deal with a big team option for 2013. Give him a chance to recoup his value and make more money in 2013. He'll be able to start but also get some rest with the Yankees having 4 viable starting OFers
2. Pick up Swisher's option. He's relatively cheap and seems to always put up an .800+OPS for the season.
3. Re-sign CC. We all know he's opting out.
4. Trade Burnett. I think the guy showed enough life late in the season to have an NL team want him for a discount. Eat as little as you can, but try to move that contract. This might be the only chance you have.
5. Must add a 1b to CC's 1a. CC is an undisputed ace. Hughes and Nova seem like a very nice complement as long as Hughes can stretch out in the offseason and come in with the velo he showed at years end. But we need a guy who can take the ball after CC and be lights out. That might be CJ Wilson. That might be a guy like Matt Cain or even the fairy tale known as King Felix. One thing is for sure, we need another effective innings eater. AJ in the 2 hole failed miserably after year 1. Nova looked nice there this yr, but he's a rookie coming off his most arduous season and left his final game with an arm injury. And after that, we're talking about kids. We need another top flight pitcher. I'd kick the tires on Matt Garza, John Danks, Gavin Floyd, etc.
6. I know I might get s*** for this, but resign Bartolo Colon. His conditioning leaves a lot to be desired, but he was money this yr, won't cost a lot and could either be our #5 starter or swing man depending on if one of the kids takes the #5 slot. After seeing the debachle of Fenway, having a viable big league contingency is necessary.
7. Let Freddy Garcia walk. He really cannot dominate with his stuff the way it is and gets hit around by patient teams, which just so happens to be all playoff bound teams sans the Rays. He's also a Type B and will probably reject arbitration. If he accepts arb, then great, but he's gonna get a 3 yr deal on the open market.
8. Offer arbitration to Cory Wade. This is a no-brainer
9. Offer arbitration to Russell Martin. Also a no-brainer
10. Pencil in Montero at the DH and backup catcher spots. The kid is fearless and has a $100 million bat. Do not trade him, he's got the chance to be one of our best offensive players next yr and a definite shot at ROY
11. Avoid dealing Nunez. He'll be a wanted man since he can play SS adequately and has a nice ceiling in terms of his offensive potential. But with ARod and Jeter being over the hill, having the young kid mature under their tutelage will be priceless.
12. Dump Chavez. Aside from a hot April, he was useless.
13. Give the kids a shot. This yr we proved that the kids can make a splash. From Nunez being a solid backup to Montero being hot as balls in September to Nova being our second best pitcher on the year. Our system is loaded and we have a lot of high end talent at the upper levels, especially on the pitching end. Don't lock yourselves into all 5 pitching spots with immovable players. This is why I want Colon. He handles himself if he needs to start, but if a rook beats him out, nobody will be calling for Cashman's head for a hideous contract.
Overall, I dont see a humongous turnover, and getting Joba back could theoretically shorten the game to 5 innings on the starters end in must win games. That's huge. Here's a proposed roster, obviously preliminary...
C- Martin
C- Montero
C- Cervelli/Romine
1B- Teixeira
2B- Cano
3B- Rodriguez
SS- Jeter
SS- Nunez
LF- Sizemore
OF- Gardner
CF- Granderson
RF- Swisher
OF- Dickerson
SP- Sabathia
SP- Wilson (or mystery SP X)
SP- Nova
SP- Hughes
SP- Colon
RP- Robertson
RP- Rivera
RP- Soriano
RP- Chamberlain
RP- Wade
RP- Logan
SP/RP- Noesi/Warren/Phelps/Mitchell/Banuelos/Betances/Kontos/etc