Bard- 42.2IP 41H 23ER 26K 25BB
That line sucks. Fangraphs has him at a xFIP of over 5. His K:BB ratio is close to 1 and he is allowing more hits than I thought he would. The "project" was to see if he could be an ace in the making. Well, if he came out firing 98mph bee bees and a knockout slider, but lacked stamina or location, then I could agree. But what he has turned into is puzzling. He has turned into a low 90s straight fastball pitcher with almost no slider to speak of and a continued reliance on a changeup that he throws almost identically in velocity to his fastball. He isnt striking people out, and with his lack of punch he has seen a massive spike in his walk rate. If you had seen a K/9 of 8 but 5IP/start and who cares about the amount of walks, I would say it is worth investigating further. But he has turned into a groundball, contact pitcher with no control or power. He's got the worst combination for success. Contact pitchers usually give up a fair amount of hits since more balls are put in play, so to this point he has been somewhat lucky (BABIP of .289). Also, since most of his contact appears to keep the ball on the ground (GB's have the highest percentage chance of a hit after line drive) he should, in essence, give up more hits than IP in this new hybrid form. Factor in the walk rate of 5.3 and you have a modern day, less effective version of Shawn Chacon out there. This is a failed project. Even if he limits hit walks, he isnt an ace out here, far from it. He is a groundball, back of the rotation pitcher with limited strikeout ability who cannot give you innings due to high pitch count. Whereas in the pen, he was a rubber armed relief ace who gave you 70 appearances of dominance over the last 2 seasons, when you needed it the most. You saw what he has now, and it is time to move on.
I'd start him one more time since you really have no other option, then move him back to the pen after Cook comes back. Then, when DiceK is finally somewhat ready, you see if he can supplant Cook until either Oswalt or a similarly acquired starter can take his place