When you have a supremely talented, veteran team, an ego manager is what you need. When you have a moderately talented, young team, a true coach is what you need. When you have an undertalented team, a game manage might win your a few. The sox are a young, supremely talented offensive team and an undertalented veteran pitching team. Farrell can manage the offensive egos and has proven his leadership allows young position players to grow and thrive. He has proven to be a horrendous game manager, especially on the pitching side, and for someone who was praised as a pitching coach, he has shown absolutely no progression in terms of development of pitching talent.