You wanna see why our team's pitching has been in the shitter?
Take a look at the drafts and signings
1985- Williams
1989- Posada
1990- Pettitte, Rivera
1991- Mendoza
1992- Jeter
Just take a look at that level of scouting. All of them hit their stride around the same time and in that class 2 sure fire HOFers and 2 ?HOFers were drafted/signed
Take a look at the drafts from the subsequent yrs
1993- best player was Chad Moeller who ended up back here
1994- Brain Buchanon was the best player and he was a AAAA guy
1995- Mike Lowell was the best player and he was dealt for Ed Yarnall
1996- Not a bad draft, but we traded it all away. Nick Johnson was dealt for Vazquez who was dealt for Johnson who was dealt for Ohlendorf, Vizcaino, and Gonzalez, Viz left and now we are just left with Ohlie, Gonzalez and a supplemental 1st rounder. Eric Milton who we dealt for Knoblauch and was a good trade at the time. And Marcus Thames who is still playing.
1997- Aaron Heilman was the best pick here and we didnt sign him
1998- Mark Prior in the first, but he didnt sign. Drew Henson and Randy Keisler were duds
1999- Andy Phillips was the best player drafted
2000-Wang in INTL signing. The draft was awful
2001- Cano, Cabrera, Duncan from both the INTL and draft. Chase Wright as well. Ford-Griffin and Sardinha were massive busts
2002- Halsey was the best player from this draft
2003- Clippard and Karstens have made the majors, and Clippard netted Alabaladejo who shows promise as a middle man. Eric Duncan, the 1st round pick, is finally hitting in his 3rd attempt at AAA but looks more like a role player
For a solid 11 yrs, we have had drafts that have either sucked or the good players we drafted were sold or given up on too early. THAT is why the pitching has gone to s***. In the meantime, we have seen teams like Boston develop a dependable closer and 2/5 of their rotation from within as well as their 2b, 1b, C, CF. Add in the Japanese moves and they made a killing off of players that they didnt have to deal away talent for. Look at a team like Oakland who put together a big 3 from within (Mulder, Hudson, Zito), blew it up then put together an even better tandem in Harden, Haren, Blanton before blowing that up too. Why were they able to build 6 all star caliber pitchers from within when we couldnt draft or sign or trade for one? The only SP all star we have had in awhile was Javy Vazquez and we all know how that yr turned out.
The days of doing things the old yankee way are out.
We got Wells as a FA reclamation project in 97.
Cone was had from the Jays to the Yankees in 95 for 3 subpar prospects to get out from under his contract even though he was still in his prime at 32.
El Duque was signed mostly because the yankees were the best known team in Cuba and not many teams thought his success in cuba would translate
Clemens was had for Wells and 2 other players past their prime or busts.
Pettitte was the only home grown talent.
You just cannot make those deals anymore. Back in the day, you could get an ace for s*** so long as you paid money for it. Teams dont do that nowadays and the only way to build a team is from within and then adding a few key pieces from outside. Cashman wont be judged by how the yankees do in 2008. Even if he is fired, he'll be judged by how the 04-now drafts and INTL signings work out. We have now restocked the farm and it will eventually work. If it takes a bit then so be it.