Age is the big factor. Damon looks like he needs a walker out there, and Abreu has been god-awful. These guys aren't getting any younger. Who's the next position player the Yanks have waiting in the wings? Tabata? He's 2+ years away at best. Your pitching may be "stacked" for the future, but honestly outside of Wang and to a lesser extent Hughes, no one has really proven themselves.
I think you overvalue your prospects highly. That's not to say some couldn't be successful, but it's highly unlikely all will have sustained big league success.
With increased revenue sharing it's going to be increasingly difficult to pluck FA's away from teams. Therefore, in order to make your lineup better you're going to have to part with some of your precious young pitching.
It's funny you mention Clemens in this part. Is Clemens's signing not the ultimate GFIN move? He's the one that was to be the savior of the Yankees season, to stabilize the rotation. It doesn't make sense to call it a rebuilding year if you throw a pro-rated $28 million at a soon to be 45 year old pitcher. Besides, you don't think the Boss wants to win it now? You don't think he'll sit idly by and watch the team go down, do you?
Fact is this second part is such a bunch of ******** that I don't even want to think about it. All offseason long you said how much of a juggernaut the Yankees were. Look, a team is never as good as they look when they're playing great and never as bad as they look when things are going bad. Do I think the division race is over? No. 12.5 games over 4 months can be made up easily. It's tough sure but it is in no way over.
********.
Duh?
Again, duh? There's a reason Dice-K was so sought after and Igawa wasn't.
I would argue the Red Sox have just as bright a future.
This is on the players and Cashman. Look, his team is not deep. That's his fault. The bullpen sucks. That's his fault. He traded away Sheffield (a RH power bat) and Johnson (an innings eater in the AL who you could count on for 14 wins), which are arguably the two things New York needs most right now. He basically fields a team that has 5 DHs in Damon, Giambi, Abreu, Matsui, and Cano.
This is on the players because they have absolutely blown ass to this point. Really, the only ones who have contributed consistently are Jeter, Posada, and Bruney, and Pettite.
s*** eating motherf***er.