So because Theo uses sabermetrics he's immune to criticism? What exactly are you trying to say here? Besides, stats are the best way to measure a player's performance.
Agreed.
That doesn't mean he, or the FO, is immune to criticism. They may have advanced scouting reports but they have made some terrible mistakes.
Again, you completely misconstrue the point because like CB said, he does what he accuses Jacko of. He sees the world in rose colored glasses. The Yankee prospects are garbage but the Sox's are gold.
I honestly don't even know how you can say that, seeing as Coco has played arguably the best CF in the majors this year. How can you say definitively that Ellsbury, a rookie who had never played in Comerica before, gets even that good a read off the bat in a park he's unfamiliar with?
I say if Coco doesn't make that catch, no one on the Sox does.