Papelbon: 5.07 Hits/9: 2.67 BB/9: 12.81 K/9: .80 HR/9: .157 BAA: .86 WHIP: 1.87 ERA
Saito: 5.39 Hits/9: .98 BB/9: 11.52 K/9: .98 HR/9: .168 BAA: .71 WHIP: 1.47 ERA
Saito's edge is definetly in the the walks since he's allowed 6 less than Papelbon. The differences are so small though, the ERA difference is one run, the HR difference is one, the hits are couple, etc. The difference in the AL and NL can't be overlooked, the league ERAs are close and Im not looking to get into a big argument but the talent level is quite a bit better in the AL. So if you want a couple walks, hits, HR, runs to sway your judgement go ahead but Im not going to call Saito's season way better than Papelbon's especially with the league difference. (Putz is hands-down the best but thats for another day).