Yes Sanchez spent a large portion of 2006 in AA and considering the benchmark for for SP jumping for AA to MLB is one spot start from Abe Alvarez, it would seem Sanchez was destined for AAA and at a bare minimum was probaly looking at 8-10 less starts in the majors, and even then the chances of him matching anywhere near his NL production in the AL is probaly slim.
Similar with Hanley, if the FO was seriously considering giving him any consideration to start 2006 as the starting SS, I think he would have gotten more than 2 AB. Again consider the bench mark during this FO's tenure, where ZERO position players have ever been given a starting a spot directly from ST out of AA. Given the FO's tendencies for calling up prospects, his .720 OPS in AA probaly meant he was staying in AA for at least the start of 2006, and probaly called up to AAA mid-season and gotten his cup of coffee in the majors towards the end of the year much like Youkillis, Pedroia, and Ellsbury have all done.
Point is you have to consider how this organization deals with young players, and the fact that it is quite different from the Marlins. I think there is reasonable doubt that Hanley and Sanchez in 2006 do not provide nearly the value they provided the Marlins in 2006, and I've stated my reasons for that. I'm of the opinion that given the way things were constructed for 2006 AND the injuries that occurred that we were not going to win the World Series that year.
This whole Beckett and Lowell trade IMO was a very good move. Someone could easily point out that Beckett was the ALCS MVP and Lowell was the World Series MVP while Hanley played for a last place team and what would be the counter for that?
But it extends past that, and this trade will reap the benefits of having Josh Beckett and possibly Mike Lowell for long past the "two obligated years." Josh Beckett's extension is so cheap compared to the 100+ mil he could get on the open market because the Red Sox had exclusive negotiation rights and Josh Beckett wanted to be on this team because he knew what came with being a Red Sox and liked it. That is a benefit of the trade. If Josh Beckett stays with the Marlins and becomes a FA, there is zero chance he signs a 3yr 30 mil deal on the open market, no chance.
Same with Lowell, IF he signs a deal worth 3/39 or something in that area, that is in large accounts a home-town discount given the year he just had. He could probaly get a 4 or 5 year deal with more money per year, and he may very well. However if he does sign that deal then this trade enables you to get 5 years of production from Mike Lowell and the reason he signed that cheaper deal was because he experienced being on the Red Sox and was willing to take a paycut to continue it. We've harped back and forth about extensions being parts of trades, and you are of the opinion that they are completely seperate. However from what I can see this organization thinks quite a bit deeper than that when making deals.