It is very difficult to carry platoon players on today's pitching heavy rosters. Benches are small. Basically, you need a catcher, and a couple of infielders and outfielders who can play multiple positions. If your roster experiences some injuries, the platoons go out the window and these platoon-type players are pressed into duty against both lefty and righty pitchers and then they are exposed as mediocre at best. Last season, when the team was very healthy, Nava and Gomes were the perfect platoon. This season with the injuries to Victorino and the under-performance of Sizemore and Bradley, Nava and Gomes had to play full time and as a result the stunk up the joint. I see very limited value in pursuing platoon situations. Roster size just doesn't afford that luxury.