Logic? Have you seen this guy play the OF? He looks like a tank on an Indy track. Numbers? He played OF on two teams in 2006. When he was on Toronto in 2006, they were a third place team. When he came to the Red Sox and played the OF for 15 games, they finished in 3rd place. Playing him in your OF is an act of desperation. He's not an OF ...period. It would be like the Yankees putting Jason Giambi in the OF. They are built alike except Hinske has a thicker neck. Erstad, on the other hand, is an OF and when healthy, he's a damn good OF. He has two gold gloves in the OF and one at 1B. Hinske is a butcher wherever he plays.