He'd never been given a consistent opportunity, because he never proved he could hit lefties or the inside pitch. He was a part time platoon type guy that wasn't a good 1B and could only play DH. His value was not high, and while talented, the flaws in his game did not indicate future super stardom. He was an appropriate risk for the Sox to take, but he was not the low risk/low reward asset that he eventually became. On the risk spectrum, he was not completely high risk either. After thinking about it more, he was not really high risk. He was a moderate risk asset because he had a fairly consistent track record, so the Sox had no reason to be concerned that he would be a total flop.