E1, for as long as you have known me, you have always been wrong about me. You still don't get me and you project onto me. I wasn't negative in 2007 or 2008. In 2009, people were worried in August that Texas and Tampa would catch us for the Wild Card. I was confident and told people that Texas and Tampa would fold, and they did. Last year, I was thrilled about our prospects going into the season, and I was completely baffled by their slow start. When late August and early September came I could see things were going badly and that they were headed for a collapse. Was I just being negative and I got lucky that time as well?
Negative? No, negative to that. Critical? Yes, but you can't honestly analyze something without being critical. If an analysis points out only strengths and good things, it's not worth anything. People who analyze like that are just pom pom wavers. Is that how I should characterize you, E1-- as a pom pom waver? I have probably logged more hours of watching baseball than many posters have been alive on this forum. When I say someone stinks, they generally stink. If I say that we don't have enough pitching, we probably don't. That's not negative. That's a rationale assessment. What's positive is that no matter how bad the Sox are I always watch them with the hope that they will win.
You say that "[t]his year it worked out for {me}". That's a really odd statement. You may enjoy them losing because it will give them a better draft choice. I am not enjoying this one bit. The losing has affected my mood this summer, and last September I had a headache every night starting at 5 pm and it got worse as the night wore on. I can watch and root and hope for my team even when I know rationally that they are not good. That's positive.
You say that "it wasn't unreasonable to think this team would be much better than it is." Well, yeah duh. I have repeatedly posted that they are far worse than I had expected them to be. I never expected them to be one of the worst teams in baseball. I never expected the wheels to come off so early, but I did know that they would not be a strong contender and that the division was probably out of reach. The second wild card was a possibility as far as I was concerned, but not the division. We came north with thin starting pitching and a closer that had never closed and no good back of the bullpen options. The injuries did not kill this team. Lousy pitching killed this team. The injury that impacted us most was the injury to bailey, and was anyone really surprised that he got injured? Strong teams are not built like that. People who analyzed the team critically could see what the pom pom wavers like yourself could not see.