It was ridiculous, because we didn't have to give up either prospects or a major leaguer. We got neither from the Cubs for Theo. We should have been able to get Farrell for the same garbage-- a bush leaguer with no major legue future. Aviles could have been used to get something of use like a bull pen arm or he could have been packaged with other playrs in a bigger deal.
Your last statement about Scutaro and Oswalt is a twisted recollecion of my position. I very clearly said several times last off season that we needed starting pitching. Ideally, they should have gotten 2 starters, but 1 was a an absolute necessity. That was the drum the I beat the entire off season. I watched as one pitcher after the other went to other teams. All that was left at the end was Edwin Jackson and Oswalt. I preferred Jackson, but then Jackson got signed by the Nats. Oswalt turned out terrible, but even if they had spent $5 million on him, the season could not have turned out worse.
It is beyond me why Sox fans will defend this unproven rube, Cherington. This is a guy who was at the helm when the Sox sunk to last place with their worst record in 50 years. He doesn't deserve the benefit of the doubt. He needs to prove himself. People are trying to defend Cherington by denigrating Aviles. I am not making any case for Aviles' greatness. I am just noting that this was an overpay for Farrell. I would have been happier if we got Darwin Barney from the Cubs for Theo, but we didn't. Aviles is as good as, maybe better than, Barney. We got recycled trash instead. It's beyond me why we couldn't just send the same to Toront.