Renfroe is a big league player. He has some big holes in his offensive game, but he produces enough power to be in the bigs. Cordero, however, is not proven big league timbre.
At least French (with a K) didn’t strikeout. How much longer do we wait on this experiment. This is not David Ortiz slumping who had a resume of a star. This guy has no real track record.
I had suggested this a while back. I would much prefer a HR derby format in extra innings instead of the man on second base rule.
https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2021/04/mlb-experiment-knock-out-home-run-derby-extra-innings.html