We agree ORS that this year it would improve the team; it is next year that you're worried about. Fine, but I happen to think that we could get at least three solid years from the guy, and for that I would more than we willing to take my chances on a guy who is hitting over 440 this spring and driving the ball. Some times you have to take a chance; you've heard of the saying--nothing ventured, nothing gained? And I don't consider it a wash. I think it is an advantage to us. I know no more than you do how this would play out over five years; I just have to go with a gut feeling.
I also don't need to hear any of that dropping that day job crap either. You say Helton improves our chances but guarantees nothing. Nothing is guaranteed, but if your team is better with him the chances are better that you will go further. You say given the option of a WS Title now and maybe suffer the consequences of such a contract later you would grab it, but you really don't want to take such a chance. Sorry my friend, usually you are clear, to the point with no doubt where you stand, but your post is a lot of double talk nonsense. You have to take chances if you want to succeed.
And, oh yes, fewer and fewer players are entering the free agent market. No s***!!!! But you tell me that some will anyway. Yeh? Who? You know for sure. You know their current teams won't resign them. We saw that happen with Wells, Ramirez and others this off season. I would rather have that bird in the hand than the two in the bush.
Now I will concede this to you and all others who are leery of such a deal. If I could be sure that the Red Sox will resign Mike Lowell to a two or three year extention I would shitcan this Helton talk in two shakes of a monkey's ass. However, I have not even heard a hint of this and I know we will need a third baseman or a first baseman next year and I don't know of any that will be available. I'd rather strike while the iron is hot. Besides, all this may be moot anyway. I haven't even heard if Helton is still available. I just know the Yankees and if a panic mode sets it they go after any player who can help them. Helton would help them as Abreu did last season. I would rather have him if we could get him.