You speak of Sabermetrics or whatever it's called as accepted scientific fact. I'll assume your "typical" comment was made because I'm defending Jeter, and thereby putting down the formulas and other stats. Not so, I've railed against these things in other threads. It has absolutely nothing to do with Jeter. I simply feel that too many people are looking at moneyball like it's the gold standard by which championships are won. Given this age of almost fanatical analysis of numbers and stats upon stats upon stats, that's not surprising, but you wonder when it will stop.
These stats don't tell you how valuable Craig Counsell has been in the playoffs or how Mark Lemke always seemed to turn it up in the playoffs. Does RISP account for the score? a guy who has a RISP of .400 in games where they're already leading by 5 before the 6th inning while facing the long relief guy can't be as clutch as the dude batting .300 RISP but does it when they're down by a run or two and facing the setup guy.
It's exaclty the reason I don't like the numbers game.