From a risk-perception, i would much rather have the Sox pitching staff then that of the Yankees. Yeah, the Yanks have Rivera, but that's about it in terms of locks. Randy is asking for an injury, Moose can be knocked around, Chacon and Small aren't exactly proven, and Wang is already showing wear-and-tear at his age.
However the Sox also have question marks. Schilling is by far the biggest, but last year was injured so what he did last year cannot really be taken seriosuly until those last three games, in which he even said on ESPNs Page 2 he wasn't injured. Beckett is next, but there's far less risk here then gossiped. Yes, he has the blister problem, but so did a man by the name of Nolan Ryan. Papelbon, who in his first career start held the Angels to 2 runs should do fine, and will be interesting to watch as the season progresses. Of course with his age comes all of the ?s as "can he take the workload" or "can he keep it up the whole season" which he probably can.
Schilling v. Johnson
Edge: NYY
I say this only because Schill is a question mark in terms of how he will perform, Johnson is whether he will get injured or not.
Beckett v. Mussina
Edge: BOS
Beckett is up and coming, Moose is going down and out, though he can obviously put up solid numbers. Mussina can be great, but can also be knocked around. I'd call it even because of Beckett coming to a new elague, etc. but I think his talnt can overcome that.
Wakefield v. Wang
Edge: BOS
Wakefiled was our anchor in the 2nd half of last year, hardly getting lit up, and coming up with the stop every time asked. Wang like Papelbon still comes with the ?s and the injury factor. Age isn't a factor for Wake as he hurls a knuckle.
Papelbon v. Chacon
Edge: Even
Up in the air, though I believe Papelbon has a far better chance to succeed over Chacon. Chacon might have always been the Chacon of last year but was dragged down by COLs thin air. However that is unlikely but only time can tell. Papelbon as stated has all the questions coming with a full workload.
Clement/Arroyo v. Small
Edge: BOS
Small, unlike Chacon was not in COL, which is Chacon's only excuse. Therefor there is more probability that last year was a fluke. Also Clement, if he can put a full season together can be great, same goes with Arroyo who was our ace the 1st half of the season along with Clement.