Yeah, because what he did in two games, coming off an injury, is really an indication of him as a whole.
Closer and Late (2006):
Jeter: 12 - 28, .429 AVG
Ortiz: 6 - 29, .207 AVG
RISP (2006):
Jeter: 22 - 59, .373 AVG
Ortiz: 18 - 69, .261 AVG
Micheal Kay might be a ball washer, but it would appear you're more than happy to join him when a Red Sox player is the topic.
And, please, nobody holds A-Rod in the company of Ortiz and Jeter when it comes to clutchness.