No, it's debatable if you open your eyes. I know I'm asking for a lot here, but stick with me. A-Rod has scored more runs, batted in more runs, hit more HRs, walked more, stolen more bases, has a better OBP, and so on. I know you'd like to ignore those, but you can't. I'm sorry.
Yeah...I'm the homer in this debate. Too funny.
When it counts he's a brick? Heh...Schilling might disagree.