its official the schilling/closing experient is ovah! After tonight it should be blatantly obvious he is no Dennis Eckersley. Hell, I'd take an Eric Gagne about now, but either way he is just not effective as a closer. I've seen some of the games where even when he did get the save, he was shaky...giving up a walk here, a double there, and I don't even want to mention the homeruns.
He wasn't exactly on fire when he left Pawtucket, but because he and mngmt were in a hurry to have him join the club asap, the thinking was even in the bullpen he might be able to work out the kinks and rediscover his game....well it hasn't happened...and even worse, he has been detrimental to the team, giving the yankees confidence about their chances to sneak back into the race for the division.
Now I appreciate what he has given the team in the past, but at this point if he's still gonna stay on the roster he needs to rejoin the rotation ASAP!!! If he is going to rediscover any semblance of he former effectiveness as a #1, its gonna be by grinding it out starting and not closing.