A case for collusion could be made. I've made no specific accusation, so I've got nothing to backtrack from, but I do feel this trade was a bit spurious. The Pirates did not, in any way, get better by this trade. They got crap in return for two marketable players at the trading deadline. You said so yourself. Hell, the draft pick compensation, which the Pirates would have gotten anyway, will be a better haul than that group, only now the Yankees will get it. They got smoked in that deal, and according to some reports (without specific names being included), they were offered more from other contending teams. Something stinks, so it's worthy of discussion, which is all we are doing at this point.
As far as you ripping anything to shreds, you can try, but you'll step all over your junk in the process like usual.