Lowell is 18 months older than ARod, but he's the only one whose return level of play is in question, and he's the one that's actually had the surgery required to make him whole. Massive contradiction.
Posada played 51 games last year. It's an overstatement that you get him back for the whole year, and his injury should limit his games as the backstop.
Matsui, like Ortiz, is dealing with a wrist and knee injury in the last two years. But Ortiz may never be the same, while Matsui only may lose a little power. Massive double standard.
Nady+Teixeira is about equivlent to Giambi+Abreu on paper. I agree it's no dropoff, but it's no sure improvement either, yet you are calling for massive improvement.
That leaves Cano, who I agree should be better than last year, but this is no sure bet, just like it's no sure bet that Pedroia and Youkilis can't repeat what they did last year, yet this assumption is gospel to you. Hell, your criteria for optimism with Cano is on their side too, as both have started the year well. But it only counts for Hollywood, right?
And, again, with little roster turnover and some give and take on their question marks, the most reasonable assumption is the Sox are about the same. I've conceded and said the Yankees improve by 100 runs, and you still aren't happy.
I've taken nothing, given a ton, this puts them at equal, and you still maintain they are clearly better. This is why I'm such a dick to you. Your view on the return from an injury, the possibility of repeating good performance, the likelihood of a rebound, etc, etc, etc, all of it is solely dependent on one thing and one thing only, which uniform the player wears. It gets old.